Polishing Weeds, or, Gems from the Vault
Last year, I started weeding the collection. All libraries weed, or should. Weeding keeps the collection current, attractive, and manageable. It’s very easy to hold on to everything – anyone with a junk drawer full of half-burned candles, lame mementos from past romances, maybe-but-I’m not sure used batteries, and old birthday cards knows this. It’s very to easy to say that that book on space travel copyright 1967 “might be good for history” or that the information in this dusty, smelly, brittle book with no jacket that hasn’t circulated in 30 years is “still good.” But we can’t hang on to everything. School libraries, especially, must maintain collections that support the school’s current curriculum. New research supersedes old. Trends in fiction age, becoming uninteresting and irrelevant to our teens. So, we weed. Sometimes the choices are easy and sometimes they’re hard, but they must be made.
These decisions are not made arbitrarily. Libraries have certain criteria by which they weed collections. Deselecting materials is just as intensive a process as selecting them, if not more so. But I don’t want to write any more about weeding — there are plenty of books, articles, and other blog posts about weeding and how it is, or should be, done. What I want to write about are some of the gems you can find when weeding. Books that really, really don’t belong in the collection anymore, but are so quaint or whacked-out or weird that you have a hard time doing whatever it is you do with books that are removed from the collection. (Again, that’s not what we’re talking about here. There are other places to read about that, and it’s a complicated question.)
I have found some outrageous things in this collection, at least outrageous by today’s standards. When I say outrageous, I mean a few different things. Some are blazingly racist or sexist. Some are so esoteric that I wonder how they got here in the first place. Some are cultural snapshots that are irresistible and fascinating to someone removed by time or space. And some are just cool! So I’d like to take this space to observe some of these and wonder about the times when these were the newest additions to our library collection. Who selected them? More importantly, who read them, and WHY??!?

